Sell Your American Eagle Silver Dollar Coins to reDollar
The American Silver Eagle – the most beautiful silver bullion coin of all time – is highly liquid and easy to trade when you work with the right buyer. reDollar.com is the #1 place to sell your American Silver Eagle coins for the highest possible price: 24/7 on our website, based on the latest silver price, with a 7-day price-lock option. reDollar.com is unmatched in buyback prices, trust, and customer satisfaction.
Right now, we pay $44.00 per coin for your American Silver Eagles, paid without any deductions.
Why reDollar.com?
✔ Top-rated company with the highest reputation score
✔ Unmatched 24/7 price lock for your Silver Eagle coins
✔ Transparent pricing with no deductions
The American Silver Dollar
Look at the beautiful, perfect details of this silver coin. Minted by the US mint, each and every coin will contain exactly one troy ounce of pure (.999) silver equaling 31.103 grams. 100% guaranteed.
Get Ready to Sell Your American Silver Eagle Collection
It’s easy and convenient to sell your American Silver Eagles with reDollar. The first step is to prepare everything you want to sell. Take your coins out of your safe deposit box or vault to count and list them. Once you know how many coins you plan to sell, getting an estimate is as easy as 1-2-3.
Pack well with padding and soundproof the contents!
Below, you will find a very well-packed collection of American Silver Eagle coins. This customer used bubble wrap to bolster the tubes and prevent them from moving in the box. Make sure to soundproof the contents – you don’t want any content-revealing noises coming from your shipping container. Most of our customers are excellent packers, which is why all packages make it safely to our laboratory.
Double-boxing your coins is an insurance requirement!
Double-boxing is not only an insurance requirement but also the best way to protect your Silver Dollars during shipping. A well-packed package will not be damaged by sorting machines or during loading and handling. Use strong tape (all around the package) to seal your valuables for a secure finish. You can be creative when choosing your filling materials – from old newspapers and bubble wrap to shredded paper – everything can be reused.
Agree & Get Paid for Your Silver Eagles
The last – and probably easiest – step in the selling process is agreeing to your final offer. If you pre-calculated your offer, we will confirm your calculation by drafting a formal offer that you can still decline. If you did not pre-calculate, we will draft and present a new offer. Look for our same-day offer in your email inbox.
Lightning Fast Payment
Once you agree to our offer and choose your preferred payment method, reDollar will issue your payment. Most transactions are paid the same day, and no later than the next business day.
reDollar.com | The Top Rated Eagle Buyer
reDollar.com is well-known and respected as one of the most reputable buyers of Silver Eagles and other silver coins in the U.S. We have revolutionized the way consumers sell their silver coins online. We feature an online silver calculator that prices your coins based on the most recent COMEX silver price. With our 7-day price-lock guarantee, consumers are immediately protected against falling prices once they lock the price. Our calculator is easy to use, and a selling order can be started and completed in as little as 5 minutes.
With reDollar.com, coin sellers get robust protection against silver price fluctuations, accessible 24/7 on their smartphone. And it’s our “we don’t hide anything in the fine print” policy that our customers like most. You will not face any negative selling surprises when you work with reDollar.
PCGS & NGCS Graded Silver Eagles
reDollar’s numismatic division is pleased to evaluate and price your PCGS, NGC, or ANACS-graded American Silver Eagles. Not every slabbed coin is a high-value Silver Eagle, but some are exceptionally rare and valuable. Our coin appraisal team will identify scarce issues such as Silver Eagles with a U.S. Army privy mark, Ryder-signed special editions, 1995-W PR70 Proof coins, or Green Label, Philadelphia-struck editions.
We also buy coins graded by ICG, CACG, ICCS, or LCGS, but we may not agree with the assigned grade. Unfortunately, it is not uncommon for PCGS or NGC to assign a lower – and sometimes significantly lower – grade than the companies listed above. PCGS and NGC are widely considered the gold standard in coin grading.
Colored, Gold-Plated & Toned Silver Eagle Coins
reDollar.com also buys decorated Silver Eagles, such as gold-plated Silver Eagles, fully colored reimagined Eagles, and toned (tarnished) Silver Eagles. When it comes to premiums paid on top of the silver price, colored or gold-plated Silver Eagles usually don’t qualify for a premium, while naturally toned Eagles – especially those with rainbow-like hues – may qualify. It depends on the intensity of the colors the coin has developed.
Uncirculated and Proof Silver Eagles can also be sold to reDollar for top dollar. In all cases, the current buyback price per coin, which is $43.77 currently, will serve as the base for premiums and discounts.
American Silver Eagles Considered Scrap
reDollar.com is also the first-choice buyer when it comes to liquidating coins considered scrap silver. Our current buy-back price for one ounce of scrap silver (.999 fine) is $37.05 per troy ounce, or $1.19 per gram. The reDollar.com silver calculator should always be your first choice to quote, price-lock, and even sell your scrap silver.
The pictured American Silver Eagle is likely the most severely damaged Eagle coin we have ever received, and it is pure speculation what may have happened to this still-beautiful coin. A good guess would have been that it was dropped into a garbage disposal, but the hole in the middle does not align with this assumption. reDollar.com salvaged the coin from being melted and retired it to the reDollar YouTube and Photo Division, which frequently uses the coin for reference.
Why not choosing another selling outlet?
Sell your American Silver Eagle coins to reDollar and enjoy a convenient, financially beneficial selling experience. We know that every day thousands of people look for a good place to sell their Silver Eagles.
Tired of local gold buyers and pawn shops offering bad deals; sometimes as little as 50 cents on the dollar?
Online auctions are also frustrating and often not very rewarding: they come with expensive selling commissions, are time-consuming, and carry risk; if there’s a problem and a buyer files a claim against you, you could lose both, your Silver Eagles and your money.
For example, if you auction off 20 Silver Eagles (one tube) at an assumed selling price of $800, the selling commissions and transaction fees will cost you about $120, netting you only $680.
| Year’s High | Year’s Low | |
| Today’s Price | $43.77 | $29.62 |
| 2024 | $32.50 | $21.90 |
| 2023 | $26.12 | $19.90 |
| 2022 | $26.94 | $17.56 |
| 2021 | $30.09 | $21.41 |
| 2020 | $29.86 | $11.64 |
| 2019 | $19.65 | $14.29 |
| 2018 | $17.70 | $13.86 |
| 2017 | $18.65 | $14.34 |
| 2016 | $20.71 | $13.58 |
| 2015 | $18.23 | $15.28 |
| 2014 | $22.05 | $15.28 |
Silver Eagle Value Trend
From 2014 to 2019, silver traded in a pretty tight range – between about $14 and $22 per troy ounce. Then 2020, the Covid year and craziness, hit like a roller coaster: the silver price plunged to $11.64 and rocketed back to $29.86 per ounce. In 2021, silver took another run at $30/ ounce, then caught its breath in 2022 and 2023, hanging out from the high teens to mid‑$20s.
In 2024, silver woke up again, finally topping out at $32.50. Let’s see how silver closes by the end of 2025.
Good to Know
The “Silver Eagle” is an American silver bullion coin denominated at one U.S. dollar. First minted in 1986, it was the first U.S. one-ounce bullion coin composed of .999 fine silver. The “Walking Liberty” design was created by Adolph Alexander Weinman in 1916, and the reverse “heraldic eagle with shield and 13 five-pointed stars” was designed by John Mercanti in 1986.
Current Silver Price: $46.31
Recommended Price to Sell:$43.77
Recommended Price to Buy:$48.63
| Specifications | |
| Denomination | $1 – One United States Dollar |
| Metal | Silver (Ag – argentum) |
| Purity | .999 pure silver (fine silver) |
| Weight (grams) | 31.1035 grams |
| Weight (troy ounce) | 1.0 |
| Diameter | 40.60 mm |
| Thickness | 2.98 mm |
| Minted since | 1986 |
| Designs | Walking Liberty, Heraldic eagle with shield and thirteen five-pointed stars. |
| Designers | Adolph A. Weinman (1916) and John Mercanti (1986) |
The American Silver Eagle: The National Treasure of Bullion Coins
One of the most recognized and pivotal coins in the world, the American Silver Eagle has been issued by the United States Mint since 1986. This coin holds a significant place in many collectors’ compilations and buyers’ portfolios due to its striking design, emblematic importance, and intrinsic silver value. This coin is a true American classic worth knowing.
What is the American Silver Eagle?
The American Silver Eagle is the official silver bullion coin of America, with each coin containing one troy ounce (31.103 grams) of .999 fine silver – with a denotation of 99.9% pure silver. The weight, purity, and content are guaranteed by the U.S. government, making it a safe medium for precious metal savings and exchange.
Specifications
The American Silver Eagle has a weight of 1 troy ounce, equal to 31.103 grams, and is composed using silver mined in the United States every year. It measures 40.6 millimeters in diameter with a thickness of 2.98 millimeters. Containing 99.9% pure silver, it holds the face value of one U.S. dollar. Although its original worth is $1, the coin’s market value depends on the current price of silver, often accompanied by a small premium due to production and demand.
A Brief History of the American Silver Eagle
The American Silver Eagle program was first sanctioned by the Liberty Coin Act of 1985, with a release date of November 24, 1986. It was originally distributed as a response to rising interest in silver financing and to aid in reducing the national stockpile of silver held by the U.S. government. Applauded for its beauty, quality, and appointed trust from the U.S. Mint, the coin gained rapid popularity among buyers and collectors alike.
Design: An Ode to Freedom and Strength
The obverse (front) of the coin holds an image of the “Walking Liberty,” originated by Adolph A. Weinman. The artwork was originally created for the half dollar in 1916. Lady Liberty can be seen marching heroically toward a sunrise, the American flag draped over her shoulders. Laurel and oak branches rest in her hands, both symbols of civil and military prestige. This image was revised to fit the Silver Eagle due to its ageless beauty and patriotic nods.
American Eagle Obverse & Reverse
The coin’s reverse (back) contains two different designs, with the 1986–2021 image displaying a heraldic eagle obscured by a shield. The originator of this depiction is the famed coin and medal designer, John Mercanti, also a retired Chief Engraver of the U.S. Mint. The second reverse design of this precious coin imagines a more naturalistic eagle taking flight – an oak branch clutched in its claws. Emily Damstra developed and implemented this design in 2021, celebrating a new era for the coin.
Types of American Silver Eagles
There are several formats these coins can be found in, each meeting specific needs for buyers and collectors. Bullion coins are the most common of these types and do not have mint marks. This version is often sold through authorized dealers and is valued depending on silver’s market price plus a small premium. Proof coins are catered toward collectors, featuring a high-quality mirror finish and mint marks, depending on location. Another variation is the burnished (or uncirculated) coin, presented with a soft matte finish. Special additions also accompany these differing American Silvers, often released to mark significant anniversaries and milestones. These include reverse proofs and enhanced finish coins, which typically hold higher premiums due to their finite mintages.
The American Silver Eagle offers a blend of American artistry, financial dependability, and reliable buyer value. Whether a beginner exploring precious metals or an experienced collector interested in unique and historically relevant pieces, the Silver Eagle provides timeless appeal with a distinct design and intrinsic worth.
Want to learn more?
American Gold Eagle
The American Gold Eagle is at least as fascinating and exciting as the American Silver Eagle. Struck in 22-karat gold and containing exactly one troy ounce of pure gold, this American bullion coin is truly valuable.
Read: American Gold Eagle